Sutter Keely is a high school senior defined by charm, popularity, and a relentless commitment to living entirely in the present moment, fueled by a flask of whiskey he carries everywhere. His philosophy of avoiding the future comes crashing down when his long-term girlfriend, Cassidy, dumps him because she wants a partner with ambition rather than a permanent adolescent. Devastated and intoxicated, Sutter wakes up the next morning on a suburban lawn, having been rescued from his stupor by Aimee Finecky, a shy, science-fiction-loving classmate who reads comic books and has never had a boyfriend.Intrigued and seeking a distraction, Sutter takes Aimee under his wing. He teaches her how to assert herself, buys her a flask of her own, and slowly draws her out of her shell. What begins as a casual rebound and an ego-boosting project transforms into genuine affection. Aimee is gentle, kind, and fully accepts Sutter’s flaws without demanding change, leading them to quickly fall in love. They share tender moments, including losing their virginities to one another, and begin envisioning a shared future after graduation.However, Sutter’s internal conflicts threaten to destroy his life. He refuses to apply to college, working a dead-end job at a men’s clothing store, and remains deeply haunted by his
absent father, who abandoned their family years ago. Desperate for closure, Sutter tracks down his father, Marcus, with Aimee’s help. The reunion is a painful disaster; Marcus is revealed to be a cynical, alcoholic gambler who cares nothing for his children. This betrayal shatters Sutter’s romanticized view of his father and forces him to confront the grim reality of his own escalating alcoholism and aimless trajectory.Panicked by the realization that he is rapidly turning into his father and that he is holding Aimee back from a bright future at college, Sutter spirals. After a violent car crash while
driving drunk with Aimee—which leaves her with a fractured arm—Sutter experiences a profound breakdown. Believing he is toxic to everyone he loves, he abruptly dumps Aimee, refusing to let her sacrifice her potential for him, and flees to a neighboring town.Months later, Sutter works a solitary job and finally confronts his inner demons, realizing he can no longer just live "now" if it means destroying tomorrow. Seeing Aimee in a reflection gives him the courage to change. He writes her a long-awaited letter, takes a sip of water instead of whiskey, and finally drives toward his future.